17 Old-Fashioned Pies Making a Big Return This Fall

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Lately, it feels like everyone’s craving a little taste of nostalgia, and what better way to get it than with a slice of something sweet and timeless? From flaky crusts to cozy spiced fillings, old-fashioned pies are making a big return and stealing the spotlight at fall gatherings. It’s like those classic recipes our grandparents swore by are finding their way back into our kitchens.

Old-Fashioned Apple Custard Pie Revival

A baked apple custard pie next to some apple slices. — Old-Fashioned Apple Custard Pie Revival. Photo credit: Easy Southern Desserts.

This fall favorite is making waves again—creamy custard, tender apples, and that buttery crust everyone remembers from Grandma’s kitchen.
Get the Recipe: Old-Fashioned Apple Custard Pie Revival

Classic Sweet Potato Pie Comeback

Velvety, spiced, and smooth—this timeless Southern pie is winning hearts again with its cozy, nostalgic flavor.
Get the Recipe: Classic Sweet Potato Pie Comeback

Lemon Chiffon Pie Makes a Sweet Return

An entire lemon chiffon pie with lemon slices on top. — Lemon Chiffon Pie Makes a Sweet Return. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

Light, fluffy, and citrusy—this lemon chiffon pie is back in style and bringing vintage dessert tables to life again.
Get the Recipe: Lemon Chiffon Pie Makes a Sweet Return

Retro Chocolate Walnut Derby Pie

A fork cutting a bite of derby pie. — Retro Chocolate Walnut Derby Pie. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

Decadent chocolate and crunchy walnuts make this retro pie a showstopper all over again—just like Grandma baked it.
Get the Recipe: Retro Chocolate Walnut Derby Pie

Classic Southern Buttermilk Pie Returns

A buttermilk pie that has been cut into slices. — Classic Southern Buttermilk Pie Returns. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

This creamy custard pie with a hint of tang is trending again—proof that Grandma’s Southern recipes never fade away.
Get the Recipe: Classic Southern Buttermilk Pie Returns

Cherry Crumb Pie Is Back in Season

Sweet-tart cherries and a buttery crumb topping are stealing the spotlight again—this old-fashioned pie is pure fall comfort.
Get the Recipe: Cherry Crumb Pie Is Back in Season

Vintage Key Lime Pie Revival

A slice being removed from a key lime pie. — Vintage Key Lime Pie Revival. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

Creamy, zesty, and cool—this no-bake lime pie is the nostalgic dessert everyone’s craving this fall.
Get the Recipe: Vintage Key Lime Pie Revival

Bourbon Chocolate Pecan Pie Returns

A piece of pecan pie being removed from a pie dish. — Bourbon Chocolate Pecan Pie Returns. Photo credit: Easy Southern Desserts.

This rich pecan pie with a hint of bourbon and chocolate is making a grand comeback—one slice and you’ll see why.
Get the Recipe: Bourbon Chocolate Pecan Pie Returns

Double Crust Blackberry Pie Comeback

A top-down view of a partially eaten blackberry pie with a lattice crust on a wire cooling rack. The pie has a crispy golden-brown crust with juicy, dark purple filling. A bowl of whipped cream is placed nearby. Crumbs and a piece of pie are visible on the table. — Double Crust Blackberry Pie Comeback. Photo credit: Easy Southern Desserts.

Juicy blackberries tucked in a buttery crust—this pie is winning hearts again as a fall must-bake classic.
Get the Recipe: Double Crust Blackberry Pie Comeback

Vanilla Pudding Pie Is Trending Again

Silky, smooth, and topped with whipped cream—this nostalgic vanilla pie is having a serious comeback this fall.
Get the Recipe: Vanilla Pudding Pie Is Trending Again

Southern Chocolate Possum Pie Returns

Layers of chocolate, cream cheese, and whipped topping make this quirky Southern pie an old-fashioned hit once again.
Get the Recipe: Southern Chocolate Possum Pie Returns

Old-School S’mores Pie Comeback

Chocolate, marshmallow, and graham cracker—this retro-inspired s’mores pie is taking over fall dessert tables again.
Get the Recipe: Old-School S’mores Pie Comeback

Classic No-Bake Turtle Pie Revival

Chocolate, caramel, and pecans meet again in this creamy pie that’s proving no-bake desserts never go out of style.
Get the Recipe: Classic No-Bake Turtle Pie Revival

Lemon Cream Pie Returns to Fame

Bright lemon flavor and creamy filling are making this retro pie a top pick for anyone craving a taste of nostalgia.
Get the Recipe: Lemon Cream Pie Returns to Fame

Coconut Custard Pie Makes a Comeback

Creamy, golden, and perfectly nostalgic—this old-fashioned coconut pie is winning fans again one slice at a time.
Get the Recipe: Coconut Custard Pie Makes a Comeback

Old-Fashioned Butterscotch Pie Revival

brown sugar pie with meringue on a white plate. — Old-Fashioned Butterscotch Pie With Meringue. Photo credit: Easy Southern Desserts.

This rich, golden butterscotch pie is pure nostalgia in every bite—smooth brown sugar custard, topped with a cloud of meringue. It’s the kind of pie your grandma swore by, and it’s making a comeback this fall.
Get the Recipe: Old-Fashioned Butterscotch Pie Revival

No-Bake Millionaire Pie Comeback

Millionaire Pie Recipe (Easy No-Bake). Photo credit: Intentional Hospitality.

This creamy no-bake Millionaire Pie blends pineapple, condensed milk, and whipped topping for a retro dessert that’s cool, creamy, and back in style this fall. You’ll see why it’s earning its name again.
Get the Recipe: No-Bake Millionaire Pie Comeback

Everyone’s Baking These Old-Fashioned Cakes Again—And Now I Get It

It’s funny how some desserts never lose their charm, and these cakes are proof of that. What once felt like old-school recipes now feel like the ultimate comfort—warm, familiar, and full of nostalgia. I didn’t expect to love them as much as I do, but after one taste, it’s clear why they’ve made such a sweet comeback.
Grab it here: Everyone’s Baking These Old-Fashioned Cakes Again—And Now I Get It