21 Old-Fashioned Pies That Still Take Center Stage Each Winter

Desserts never go out of style, and these old-fashioned pies are proof. From flaky crusts to cozy fillings, they bring warmth, nostalgia, and a touch of magic to winter kitchens. Every bite feels like a celebration of tradition, and once you make them, it’s easy to see why they keep stealing the show.

Key Lime Mousse Pie

A slice being removed from a key lime pie. — Key Lime Mousse Pie. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

Tart lime and creamy filling meet in this no-bake favorite Grandma always served cold. It’s light, tangy, and hard to stop at one bite.
Get the Recipe: Key Lime Mousse Pie

Lemon-Lime Beach Pie

A slice of pie next to an entire pie. — Lemon-Lime Beach Pie. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

This old-fashioned beach pie mixes lemon, lime, and a salty crust Grandma loved. It’s the kind of pie that tastes like sunshine and good company.
Get the Recipe: Lemon-Lime Beach Pie

Grandma’s Lemon Chess Pie

Bright, tangy, and baked until golden—this chess pie is pure nostalgia. It’s the kind Grandma always saved one extra slice of for herself.
Get the Recipe: Grandma’s Lemon Chess Pie

Grandma’s Turtle Pie With Chocolate & Caramel

Just like Grandma made it—this creamy chocolate caramel pie with pecans and a cookie crust is pure nostalgia in every bite.
Get the Recipe: Grandma’s Turtle Pie With Chocolate & Caramel

Old-Time Lemon Cream Pie That Brightens the Day

A tangy lemon curd and cream cheese pie that tastes like sunshine—Grandma would never stop at one slice.
Get the Recipe: Old-Time Lemon Cream Pie That Brightens the Day

Grandma’s Coconut Custard Pie Delight

Sweet, creamy, and filled with toasted coconut—this old-fashioned custard pie brings back Sunday suppers with Grandma.
Get the Recipe: Grandma’s Coconut Custard Pie Delight

Apple Custard Pie Just Like Grandma’s

A baked apple custard pie next to some apple slices. — Apple Custard Pie Just Like Grandma’s. Photo credit: Easy Southern Desserts.

Tender apples and creamy custard baked in a flaky crust—this pie tastes like Grandma’s kitchen on a fall afternoon.
Get the Recipe: Apple Custard Pie Just Like Grandma’s

Creamy Sweet Potato Pie Worth Every Slice

Silky smooth and spiced to perfection, this old-fashioned sweet potato pie will make Grandma proud every time.
Get the Recipe: Creamy Sweet Potato Pie Worth Every Slice

Grandma’s Bourbon Pecan Pie With Chocolate

Rich, nutty, and kissed with bourbon—this chocolate pecan pie tastes like Grandma’s Southern charm in dessert form.
Get the Recipe: Grandma’s Bourbon Pecan Pie With Chocolate

Old-Fashioned Blackberry Pie With Flaky Crust

A top-down view of a partially eaten blackberry pie with a lattice crust on a wire cooling rack. The pie has a crispy golden-brown crust with juicy, dark purple filling. A bowl of whipped cream is placed nearby. Crumbs and a piece of pie are visible on the table. — Old-Fashioned Blackberry Pie With Flaky Crust. Photo credit: Easy Southern Desserts.

Juicy blackberries bubble under a buttery crust—just the kind of pie Grandma pulled from the oven for Sunday supper.
Get the Recipe: Old-Fashioned Blackberry Pie With Flaky Crust

Grandma’s Creamy Vanilla Pudding Pie

Smooth, silky, and simple—this creamy vanilla pudding pie is the kind of classic Grandma always kept chilled for guests.
Get the Recipe: Grandma’s Creamy Vanilla Pudding Pie

Layered Possum Pie Grandma Couldn’t Resist

Layers of chocolate, cream cheese, and pecans make this retro Possum Pie a Southern treat Grandma always loved sharing.
Get the Recipe: Layered Possum Pie Grandma Couldn’t Resist

Old-Fashioned S’mores Pie by the Oven Light

Chocolate, marshmallow, and graham cracker meet in this cozy pie that brings Grandma’s fireside sweetness home.
Get the Recipe: Old-Fashioned S’mores Pie by the Oven Light

Grandma’s Cool Lemon Icebox Pie

A creamy pie with a golden brown graham cracker crust is partially cut, revealing its smooth texture. A slice of this delectable lemon dessert is placed on a white scalloped plate nearby, next to another plate holding lemon wedges and silver utensils. A grey napkin lies beneath the plates. — Grandma’s Cool Lemon Icebox Pie. Photo credit: Easy Southern Desserts.

Sweet, creamy, and perfectly chilled—this lemon icebox pie is a timeless recipe Grandma swore.
Get the Recipe: Grandma’s Cool Lemon Icebox Pie

Chocolate Cherry Pie Grandma Loved Best

A bite of chocolate pie with cherries on t plate. — Chocolate Cherry Pie Grandma Loved Best. Photo credit: Easy Southern Desserts.

Deep chocolate, bright cherries, and a flaky crust come together for a pie Grandma never left a crumb of.
Get the Recipe: Chocolate Cherry Pie Grandma Loved Best

Grandma’s Strawberry Icebox Pie

A strawberry pie topped with whipped cream. — Grandma’s Strawberry Icebox Pie. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

Sweet strawberries meet a salty pretzel crust for a cool, creamy dessert Grandma couldn’t resist sharing.
Get the Recipe: Grandma’s Strawberry Icebox Pie

Classic Chocolate Pie With Fluffy Frosting

Whole chocolate meringue pie with a slice taken out, set on a plate with a cloth napkin beside it. — Old-Fashioned Chocolate Pie With Seven-Minute Frosting. Photo credit: Easy Southern Desserts.

Rich, custardy chocolate meets airy seven-minute frosting for a timeless treat. This classic pie is perfect for a secret midweek indulgence.
Get the Recipe: Old-Fashioned Chocolate Pie With Seven-Minute Frosting

Old-Fashioned Strawberry Chiffon Pie

strawberry chiffon pie with a side of forks. — Old-Fashioned Strawberry Chiffon Pie. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

Light, airy, and perfectly pink—this vintage strawberry chiffon pie is the kind Grandma made for special Sundays.
Get the Recipe: Old-Fashioned Strawberry Chiffon Pie

Chocolate Walnut Derby Pie

A fork cutting a bite of derby pie. — Chocolate Walnut Derby Pie. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

Rich chocolate and toasted walnuts tucked in a flaky crust—Grandma never skipped this Southern favorite for holidays or Sunday dinner.
Get the Recipe: Chocolate Walnut Derby Pie

Classic Southern Buttermilk Pie

A buttermilk pie that has been cut into slices. — Classic Southern Buttermilk Pie. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

That sweet custard and hint of tang make this buttermilk pie a true Southern treasure. Grandma always said it’s best warm with a little whipped cream.
Get the Recipe: Classic Southern Buttermilk Pie

Chocolate Covered Strawberry Pie

Layers of chocolate and strawberries come together in this dreamy no-bake pie. It’s the kind Grandma made when she wanted dessert fast but special.
Get the Recipe: Chocolate Covered Strawberry Pie

I Don’t Save Recipes Often, but These 19 Desserts Earned a Spot

I don’t bookmark every recipe, but these desserts deserve a place on repeat—they’re that memorable. Each one brings a special twist, whether it’s creamy and indulgent or rich and chocolatey, leaving flavors that stay with you long after the last bite. They’re the kind of sweet treats that turn baking into a little celebration every time.
Get the Recipe: I Don’t Save Recipes Often, but These 19 Desserts Earned a Spot